Conservation

Depths of sanctuary

Words by Violet Sage Walker
Photographs by Alex Krowiak
Additional photographs by Kate Powell

October 23rd marks the 50th anniversary of the U.S. National Marine Sanctuaries Act. Violet Sage Walker, Chairwoman of the Northern Chumash Tribal Council, explains what the designation of the first Indigenous-led sanctuary, the Chumash Heritage National Marine Sanctuary, would mean to conservation and the Chumash People.

The National Marine Sanctuary system is a network of protected waters encompassing more than 600,000 square miles of our ocean, coasts, and Great Lakes. It is home to millions of species, promotes access to ocean exploration for people from all walks of life, and is critical to developing the next generation of ocean conservationists. There are currently 16 sanctuaries in the National Marine Sanctuary system and my greatest hope is that there may soon be a 17th with a designation of the Chumash Heritage National Marine Sanctuary.

I grew up on ancestral Chumash land on the Central Coast of California in an area bounded by the Monterey Bay National Marine Sanctuary to the north, and the Channel Islands National Marine Sanctuary to the south. These two sanctuaries provided education and outreach programmes that allowed me to become familiar with all that marine sanctuaries had to offer. It was here, where I learned scuba diving, kayaking, whale watching, and habitat conservation. My first visit to the world-famous Monterey Bay Aquarium fascinated me. I spent most of the trip glued to the diving demonstration watching divers feeding fish and thinking: “That’s going to be my job one day.” Like so many, I became utterly enamoured with sea otters – both inside the aquarium and those floating in the bay – and learned about the aquarium’s conservation effort to protect this species alongside the Monterey Bay National Marine Sanctuary. I began diving shortly after and was certain that I would become the next Jacque Cousteau. My main diving spot became the kelp forests off the Channel Islands National Marine Sanctuary. I tried lobster diving, hunted for scallops and dove at night. I became obsessed. The ocean was everything to me. It was my sanctuary, and I knew that I had to protect it.

By the time I was 12 years old, a Chumash Elder, Pilulaw Khus, sought out my dad. She needed help protecting the coastline from development both on and offshore. Pilulaw chose my dad because he was self-taught in law and knew his way around computers and technology; he was a powerful force of nature. She needed someone who had experience in negotiating, and he was fearless on her behalf. Pilulaw taught us who we were and showed us that Chumash people have always been on the frontlines of conservation. The Chumash people have lived along the same stretch of California coastline for the last 15,000 to 20,000 years. They are maritime people. Before colonisation, you would have seen a thousand of our canoes, called tomols, along the coastline because our people lived and traded by the ocean. Our stories and our songs are based on the ocean. The ocean is in our blood. It has always been a sanctuary for us.

Before I even knew what Native Americans or Chumash were, I had already been in love with the ocean. I grew up along Avila and Shell Beach, and have always found wonder in the waves along the shoreline. But it was the diving, the getting to explore offshore realms, that really filled my soul and made me want to become a protector of this beautiful place.

Luckily, the education and outreach programmes the National Marine Sanctuaries provide are some of the most impactful STEM and conservation programmes among the Federal Government’s many natural resource agencies. These programmes help draw in children – children like me – into the sciences and conservation. The early education programme in particular, produces some extraordinarily committed ocean conservationists – myself included. Yet, the National Marine Sanctuary system remains severely under-resourced compared to its terrestrial counterparts. The Office of National Marine Sanctuaries manages over 600,000 square miles. The National Park Service manages a little over 130,000 square miles. Last year, the Office of National Marine Sanctuaries received a budget of $60.5 million, while the National Park Service was given a budget of over $3 Billion. That amounts to just $0.14/acre to support management, scientific research, and education in all 16 marine sanctuaries plus two marine monuments, compared with an average of $29.76/acre for the National Park system. Despite this, the sanctuaries do an admirable job of making every dollar count. By investing their limited resources into STEM education and outreach to nature-deprived and marginalised communities, they are developing underrepresented people into ocean scientists, educators, and advocates. I believe that it is critically important to have diverse racial and cultural communities represented in these disciplines because each has a different relationship and history with the ocean and can bring new perspectives and ideas to the policy table. Intersections across a diverse group of people can allow policy-makers to see new problems and discover new types of solutions.

Adding our voice brings in ancestral stewardship knowledge unique to the area; we are the local experts. Integrating and engaging the traditional knowledge of Indigenous people in partnership with scientists is the necessary path forward in conservation. We consider the preservation of tribal spiritual, natural, and cultural resources to be our heritage and responsibility.

Eight years ago, my dad, as the chairperson of the Northern Chumash Tribal Council, held a meeting of local grassroots activists in his home to discuss the best way to protect our cultural waters in this modern era. We came to the conclusion that the path forward was to push for National Marine Sanctuary status. Our advisors from Sierra Club, Surfrider, and National Marine Sanctuary Foundation said the sanctuary system has always brought people together from every walk of life. And this is exactly what Chumash cultural waters have been doing for millennia; bringing people together and providing sanctuary for all.

As the first Indigenous-led sanctuary nomination, Chumash Heritage would encompass 156 miles of coastline and bridge the physical gap of protections between the Monterey Bay and Channel Islands national marine sanctuaries. Within the proposed sanctuary boundaries is an area called Humqaq’ – Point Conception, we call it the ‘Western Gate’ – where we believe our souls leave this world and go into the next. Indigenous peoples have come together in ceremony for our ancestry and our loved ones passing on to Similaqsa, paradise, for millennia. Humqaq’ is a Chumash ceremonial sanctuary and it is essential to have heightened protection for this space.

Marine sanctuary designation also made sense for the Chumash to maintain the integrity of our cultural fishing practices. National marine sanctuaries can allow for some types of fishing, with regulations varying by sanctuary,  while also promoting sustainable usage. For traditional coastal communities like the Chumash, seafood is an important part of our diet and culture. National marine sanctuaries are also good for local economies, bringing in revenue from tourism and outdoor recreation interests to the surrounding communities.

While each sanctuary has its own set of regulations, designation includes protection from offshore oil and gas exploration and protection from seabed disturbance. The offshore area of the proposed Chumash Heritage National Marine Sanctuary has prime, deepwater upwelling that supports unique flora and fauna; an area with historical shipwrecks and thousands of ancient offshore Chumash cultural sites. A ban of these very destructive resource extraction practices is imperative to preserving Chumash heritage.

In 2015, on behalf of the Northern Chumash Tribal Council, my dad, Chief Fred Collins, officially nominated Chumash Heritage National Marine Sanctuary through the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s (NOAA) public nominations process. While it was a momentous occasion, it also turned out to be the beginning of a long and arduous process. NOAA’s National Marine Sanctuary public nomination process had just re-opened after a 20 year stall. While it is meant to encourage nominations from grassroots efforts by communities to protect the special places they live in, the main problem is that the process has no funding mechanism to support these bottom-up efforts. Most people don’t know how the nomination process or the federal policy space works. We were fortunate to have P.J. Webb as an advisor on our side. P.J. has served on the Monterey Bay Sanctuary’s Advisory Council in different capacities for over 15 years, and she was invaluable in walking us through the red tape and helping us get the nomination through NOAA’s front door.

It quickly became apparent to me, my dad, and P.J. that getting NOAA to accept a sanctuary nomination and put it in their inventory for possible designation requires plentiful financial and technical resources. A nomination, it turns out, is only as successful as the community support it can garner, so it was important for us to run outreach and public support campaigns, which we didn’t have the money or time to do. We initially had to rely on funds from our jobs and personal donations from the community to get us through. I was also working 50 to 60 hours a week – and going back to school full time. There simply weren’t enough hours in the day to also do fundraising and campaigning. That’s when our partners stepped in and provided the resources needed for research, reports, print materials, and meetings.

We were constantly learning, and putting in long hours – nearly a decade of our lives talking to everyone who would listen. Everything we did in the beginning was literally by sheer force of will to make it work, but it paid off when the nomination was accepted in 2015. Then the Administration changed and the whole process came to a grinding halt…

This is only a short excerpt of the story. Read the full story, Depths of sanctuary, in Issue 24 of Oceanographic Magazine. 

Photographs by Alex Krowiak
Additional photographs by Kate Powell

Related stories

Explore the current issue

Beautiful photography. Captivating storytelling.
Take a look inside the latest issue of Oceanographic Magazine.

Explore and bUY

DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTIONS

Subscribe to the digital edition for just £20 a year, or enjoy it for free courtesy of Oceanographic’s partnership with Marine Conservation Society. No cost, no catch.

Read more